Choosing Between PLCs and PCs for Industrial Automation: Advantages and Considerations

Introduction: In this article, we'll explore the preference for Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs) over Personal Computers (PCs) in the context of automation and industrial control systems. We will also discuss the emergence of Industrial PCs as a new player in the field.

Understanding PLCs and PCs: PLCs, introduced in the 1970s, were created to replace hard-wired relays and timers with user-programmable software. They consist of proprietary microprocessors and operating systems. PCs, on the other hand, were originally designed as single-user desktop computers but have evolved into laptops, tablets, and smartphones, each capable of performing PC functions.

Key Differences:

1. Operating Systems: PLCs have proprietary operating systems, while PCs run popular OSs like Microsoft Windows, Mac OS, or Chrome OS.
2. Programming: PLCs use proprietary software (e.g., Rockwell Studio 5000 or Siemens TIA Portal) for programming, following IEC 61131-3 standard languages. PCs typically use higher-level languages like C++.
3. Execution: PLCs follow a scan-based program execution, while PC software operates on an event-driven basis.
4. Environment: PLCs are designed for harsh industrial environments, while PCs are intended for friendly office settings.
5. Security: PLCs are inherently resistant to viruses and cyberattacks, whereas PCs are more susceptible.

Advantages of PLCs:

1. Robustness: PLCs are built to withstand harsh industrial conditions, such as extreme temperatures and environmental challenges.
2. Reliability: They are reliable and easy to troubleshoot, and their proprietary OS adds an extra layer of protection against cyber threats.
3. Expandability: PLCs can easily accept expansion modules, facilitating various industrial communication protocols.
4. Widespread Use: PLCs find applications across diverse industries, from sawmills to oil refineries.

The Rise of Industrial PCs: In recent years, Industrial PCs have emerged as a viable alternative to both PLCs and traditional PCs. These rugged computers are designed for tough environments, offering the capability to run applications beyond control functions. However, they come with the familiarity of the Windows operating system.

Advantages of Industrial PCs:

1. Versatility: Industrial PCs can perform control functions and run a wide range of applications not possible on PLCs.
2. Familiarity: The Windows OS is well-known, making programming more accessible to a broader range of IT professionals.
3. Rugged Design: Industrial PCs are built to endure harsh conditions, making them suitable for industrial settings.

Conclusion: While PLCs have been a staple in industrial automation due to their reliability and robustness, the emergence of Industrial PCs has expanded the possibilities for automation and control. The choice between PLCs, PCs, or Industrial PCs should be made based on specific project requirements, environmental conditions, and programming expertise. Industrial PCs, with their versatility and familiarity, are increasingly becoming a noteworthy option in the world of industrial automation.

 

OstBridge is based on the market in China and Europe to provide our clients with original HEIDENHAIN, PRECIZIKA, SIEMENS, B & R, BOSCH REXROTH, EATON VICKERS, PARKER, Large stock, accept MOQ, fast delivery If you are looking for the fields of precise motion control, electronic control, automation, and hydraulic system, the OstBridge team must be your first choice to bring you the right solution.